The three clear, but nuanced, distinctions it made are a valuable contribution to. Aruna shanbaug meets most of the criteria for being in a permanent vegetative state which has resulted for 37 years. Mathura, a 16yearold tribal girl, was raped by two policemen in the compound of desai ganj police station in maharashtra on march 26, 1972. Union of india raises important questions about the meaning of life, death and their relationship to law and to state power. It is stated in the writ petition that the petitioner aruna ramachandra shanbaug was a staff nurse working in king edward memorial hospital. Shanbaug was a staff nurse working in king edward memorial hospital, parel. Supreme court delivers historic judgment on aruna shanbaug. The top court in 2011 had recognised passive euthanasia in aruna shanbaug case by which it had permitted withdrawal of lifesustaining treatment from patients not.
Search and upload all types of judgement on aruna shanbhag case projects for mbas on. This case, which was finally decided by this court by its judgment dated december, 1996, has been placed before us for determination of the quantum of pollution fine. Misadventures of the supreme court in aruna shanbaug. It is now wellsettled principle that past practices and conventions form a precedent and followed unless decided otherwise. The case before us is a writ petition under article 32 of the constitution, and has been filed on behalf of the petitioner, aruna ramachandra shanbaug by one ms pinki virani of mumbai, as a next friend. She has the worlds most dubious distinction of being the longestknown such case. When we combine the consent part voluntary and non. Recent legal judgements indicate better days for home buyers from penalties to refunds, the national consumer disputes redressal commission has passed several orders against builders for their failure to deliver projects. It also did not deal with the indian statutory position at all to support its decision.
Like the delhi gang rape case of 16 december 2012, family members of three of the accused cried foul play and claimed that their children were minors. This would mean that the existence of the board, as such, is in perpetuity. Shreya singhal and 66a centre for internet and society. Aruna shanbaug the woman who triggered the debate on. The cc judgment has also extensively deliberated on the misreading of s the gian kaur judgment 7 by the twojudge bench in the shanbaug case 6. The article looks at the life of aruna shanbaug and analyzes the supreme court judgement allowing passive euthanasia.
The three clear, but nuanced, distinctions it made are a valuable contribution to indian jurisprudence and. Best health and medical news portal in india my medical mantra. Posts about aruna shanbaug case written by kracktivist. Supreme court and indias forests armin rosencranz, sharachchandra lele the t n godavarman vs union of india case in the supreme court, also known as the forest case, is an example of the judiciary overstepping its constitutional mandate.
It affirms unambiguously the right to refuse life support interventions as. However, in the instant case, aruna could breathe by herself and did not need any external assistance to breath and thus, distinguished from the mckay case. May, 2016 at some point in your life, through friends, popular media or your school or college, you must have come across the term mercy killing. The digest of supreme court cases the supreme court digest of recent cases is a compilation of digest notes of the recent supreme court case law. The court has effectively taken over the daytoday governance of indian forests leading to negative. This is the clear position of a landmark judgment quoted in the aruna shanbaug case. Everything you need to know about aruna shanbaug, whose. Mar 07, 2011 refusing mercy killing of aruna shanbaug, lying in a vegetative state for 37 years in a mumbai hospital, a twojudge bench of justices markandeya katju and gyan sudha mishra, laid a set of tough. With the concept of euthanasia, law enters that complex territory of medical ethics which has even divided the medical fraternity sharply in the recent past. In danial latifi, the supreme court set right many of the flaws in the shah bano judgement, whilst taking care not to put its foot in the mouth, as it had in the shah bano case with its contemptuous tone and. Aruna ramchandra shanbaug 1 june 1948 18 may 2015, was an indian nurse who was at. Union of india, 2014 9 scc 1 constitution of india arts. Vs union of india citation 1995 air 1531 court india level of court. Aruna shanbaug case supreme court of india 14522 words.
It is a writ petition under article 32 of the indian constitution. Supreme court modifies order in assam detention centres case sclaw april, 2020 we are a group of advocates, based at chamber no 70, new courts, jalandhar 144001, punjab, india. She sustained severe injuries resulting in brain damage, because of which she has been in a permanent vegetative state for the past 37 years. This compilation is fully searchable, and looks up words or phrases in the supreme court digest of recent cases and displays the casenote where your search term occurs. Supreme court decision on aruna ramachandra shanbaug versus union of india pdf. Hons, 3rd year institute of law nirma university, ahmedabad 382481.
The decision was made as part of the verdict in a case involving aruna shanbaug, who had been in a persistent vegetative state pvs for 42 years until her death in 2015. Constitutional and legal protection for life support limitation in. The top court in 2011 had recognised passive euthanasia in aruna shanbaug case by which it had permitted withdrawal of lifesustaining treatment from patients not in a position to make an informed decision. Jun 10, 2015 in the aruna shanbaug judgment, the supreme court produced one of its finest verdicts. Mar 09, 2018 the need to change euthanasia laws was triggered by the famous aruna shanbaug case. The case for india for india by will durant intro of the book this indiancivilization, evidently, was not a minor civilization produced an inferior people. Aruna shanbaug has not walked or spoken a word in 37 years. Aruna shanbaug judgement pdf the supreme court on friday declared that its judgment in the case of aruna shanbaug is flawed. It ranks with the highest civilizations of history, and some, like keyserling, would place it at the head and. Aruna shanbaug, a 61 year old woman has been in a vegetative state for the past 38 years, now the sc rejects her plea of mercy killing stating that man cannot take anything away which it cannot give.
The case concerns unlawful detention under the special powers act, 1974 spa. Sema sema, j i had the privilege of reading the draft judgments prepared by my learned brothers shah,j. Premature baby born at 375 grams survives, beating all odds. Reliance was placed on the landmark judgement of airedale nhs trust v. About europe pmc funders joining europe pmc governance roadmap. Baby girl cherry was born to proud parents nitika and saurabh hailing from chhattisgarh and delivered at rainbow childrens hospital in hyderabad. That is what has been done by the law commission of india in its 196th report and the supreme court of india in the very recent case of aruna shanbaug. The story of aruna shanbaug is by now likely to be familiar to all readers of ijme, after its walltowall coverage in the news countrywide in the second week of march 2011. Best health and medical news portal in india my medical. Bland, quoting extensively from the judgment and relying almost entirely on it, without considering that the law stated there is contrary to the indian position.
Mar 10, 2018 the case revolves around aruna shanbaug, a 60 years old woman who was violently raped in 1973. Pinki virani had filed a plea in seeking that aruna shanbaug, who lived in a vegetative state for decades after a brutal rape, be allowed. Why ward boy wasnt charged with rape aruna shanbaug, once a nurse at kem hospital and then a patient for 42 years, lost her agonizing battle with life on monday. Here too, the focus is on feminist legal scholarship because it is in the field of law that literature was generated by indian legal feminists after the mathura case. Since she was raped by a sweeper at her hospital in 1973, she has not. Here too, the focus is on feminist legal scholarship because it is in the field of law that literature was generated by indian legal feminists after the. The mathura rape case was in a way one of the most outrageous cases in the history of indian judiciary. Jul 18, 2018 the landmark judgement of airedale nhs trust v. The supreme court digest of recent cases is a compilation of digest notes of the recent supreme court caselaw. The judgement set a precedent for invalidating most detentions under the spa. Aruna ramachandra shanbaug finally breathed her last in may 2015, after being in a permanent vegetative state pvs for over 40 years. In the aruna shanbaug judgment, the supreme court produced one of its finest verdicts.
In march 2011, the supreme court of india passed a historic judgement law permitting passive euthanasia in. I am broadly in agreement with the conclusion reached at by brother shah,j. This is a research report on judgement on aruna shanbhag case by rahul tripathi in case study category. The mother of one accused even presented a school leaving certificate next day when he was nabbed. Government of bangladesh 1975 27 dlr hcd 122 is a case of the high court division of the supreme court of bangladesh. Aruna shanbaugs death provides a strong case for legalising euthanasia india aruna shanbaug case the recent death of aruna shanbaug, who was a nurse at the kem hospital in mumbai, has sparked alive the debate on euthanasia. I visit her frequently and my last visit to her was on 22nd february, 2011. However, her dementia has not progressed and has remained stable for many years.
The nurse was assaulted and sexually harassed by a ward boy on the night of 27th november, 1973. On 7 march 2011, the supreme court, in a landmark judgement, issued a set of broad guidelines legalizing passive. At some point in your life, through friends, popular media or your school or college, you must have come across the term mercy killing. Aruna shanbaug, a mumbai nurse who was raped in 1973 by a ward boy at the hospital she worked in, has died after being in a coma for 42 years. Mar, 2011 thus, the supreme court in aruna shanbaug blindly relied on airedale v. This case placed the authority to decide whether a case is fit or not for euthanasia in the hands of the court. Supreme court judgment has upheld suicide laws that may potentially be. M sahai summary of facts the present case has 4 petitioners.
It may be stated that the main case was disposed of with the following directions. Aruna ramchandra shanbaug 1 june 1948 18 may 2015, was an indian nurse who was at the centre of attention in a court case on euthanasia after spending 42 years in a vegetative state as a result of sexual assault. Judgement on aruna shanbhag case by rahul tripathi in case. His identical twin brother cass is newly released from prison, 25 years after pleading guilty to the murder of his girlfriend, dita kronon. The supreme courts decision this week in aruna shanbaug v. Case briefing is a way of presenting a case in a systematic way in order to determine the most relevant facts, identify the legal issues involved, arguments from the opposite parties. This would make it 39 years in this semicomatose condition after she was sodomised and left for dead in november 1973. Identical pdf epub download by scott turow pdf, epub, mobi free download state senator paul giannis is a candidate for mayor of kindle county. Misadventures of the supreme court in aruna shanbaug v. Everything you need to know about aruna shanbaug, whose case led to indias euthanasia debate.
Jan 07, 2015 reliance was placed on the landmark judgement of airedale nhs trust v. A study of impact on role of independent directors ravi thakur student b. The need to change euthanasia laws was triggered by the famous aruna shanbaug case. This compilation is fully searchable, and looks up words or phrases in the supreme court digest of recent cases and displays the case note where your search term occurs. The legal term for mercy killing is euthanasia and the consequences of legalising it, have over time, become a heated debate among indias intellectual, political and legal circles. Pdf euthanasia has always been a conflict between life and death, for some it. The madhya pradesh government provided reservation in promotion to the scheduled castes and scheduled tribes in the public department. Unfortunately the judgment in the case not only fails to grapple adequately with these issues, but also betrays faulty legal reasoning and an utter disregard for the law and the legal process. A fair balance has to be struck and a holistic approach has to be taken. The case for india english will durant internet archive. Aruna shanbaug s death provides a strong case for legalising euthanasia india aruna shanbaug case the recent death of aruna shanbaug, who was a nurse at the kem hospital in mumbai, has sparked alive the debate on euthanasia. Ethics and legality of euthanasia in indian context semantic scholar.
A woman in bombay, india called aruna shanbaug turns 64 on june 1 today. It was stated that the petitioner aruna ramachandra shanbaug was a staff nurse. The chapter on the shah bano judgement also covers the danial latifi case which succeeded it. Aruna ramchandra shanbaug 1 june 1948 18 may 2015, was an indian nurse who was at the centre of attention in a court case on euthanasia after spending 42 years in a vegetative state as a result of sexual assault in 1973, while working as a junior nurse at king edward memorial hospital, parel, mumbai, shanbaug was sexually assaulted by a ward boy, sohanlal bhartha walmiki, and remained. Police have made them go through medical tests and it. The decision was criticized for being an ultravires action and breaching the law of equality and provisions laid down in the nagaraj case. The shreya singhal order is said to be unprecedented at least for the last four decades and also precedent set. Aruna shanbaug the woman who triggered the euthanasia debate in india 3. Markandey katju, gyan sudha misra reportable in the supreme court of india criminal original jurisdiction writ petition criminal no. Euthanasia arguments in favour and against clearias. Refusing mercy killing of aruna shanbaug, lying in a vegetative state for 37 years in a mumbai hospital, a twojudge bench of justices markandeya katju and gyan sudha mishra, laid a.
Because of the aruna shanbaug case, the supreme court of india has permitted passive euthanasia, which means that arunas state will worsen with. Court referred to the decision of the bombay high court in. In the case of cabe, the terms of nominated members is only for three years but for exofficio members there is no fixed term of office. Everything you need to know about aruna shanbaug, whose case.
Purpose the judgment of aruna shanbaug case suggests that passive euthanasia can be considered. May 19, 2015 on november 27, 1973, aruna shanbaug who worked as a junior nurse at the kings edward memorial hospital in mumbai, was brutally assaulted and raped by a wardboy. The court in its judgment also requested the constitution to abolish section 309 of the ipc attempt to suicide, giving the reason that the. On november 27, 1973, aruna shanbaug who worked as a junior nurse at the kings edward memorial hospital in mumbai, was brutally assaulted and raped by a wardboy. The public trust doctrine, as discussed by us in this judgment is a part of the law of the. Supreme court delivers historic judgment on aruna shanbaug case. The cc judgment 1 has resolved the discord and contradictions therein. From the above examination by the team of doctors, it cannot be said that aruna shanbaug is dead. Aruna shanbaug, a mumbai nurse who was raped in 1973 by a ward boy at the hospital she worked in, has died after being in a coma for 42. It is stated in the writ petition that the petitioner aruna ramachandra.
Case concerning determination of quantum of fine to be imposed for pollution caused to river judgment in the case on the rest of points was delivered in the previous m. Whatever the condition of her cortex, her brain stem is certainly alive. The supreme courts verdict on friday legalising passive euthanasia owes much to the aruna shanbaug case, around. In march 2011, the supreme court of india passed a historic judgement law permitting passive euthanasia in the country. However in the present case, as no indication of aruna shanbaug s views or wishes with respect to lifesustaining treatments for a permanent vegetative state, any decision regarding her treatment will have to be taken by a surrogate i. Recent legal judgements indicate better days for home. Shreya singhal vs union of india 2015 on sections of the information technology act of 2000, so i have tried to summarise a variety of views of experts in this article. In 1973, aruna shanbaug, a vivacious 24yearold nurse at mumbais kem hospital was savagely assaulted, sodomised and strangulated by a wardboy in the hospital. This case is being focused on because it reflects the ambiguous nature of the rape law and its implementation.
1102 901 84 851 166 114 533 275 1556 240 1305 1081 1337 1011 1039 1466 818 1299 1338 536 1394 549 628 506 192 1607 1106 182 478 868 1385 1352 270 315 858 275 297 1242